
Extended protection for products beyond the driveway
A washing machine stops working after its original warranty expires. A sofa needs an eligible repair. A retailer wants to offer customers additional protection at checkout.
These situations lead to the same question: which extended warranty company fits the product and the customer? The answer depends on the actual plan, its exclusions and the process for getting help.
This shortlist covers five extended warranty companies and product protection providers for electronics, appliances, furniture and other retail purchases. It focuses on non-auto programmes available in the US, with a separate look at what retailers need from a provider.
- Allstate Protection Plans, Asurion, Extend, Assurant and Mulberry offer different approaches to non-auto product protection.
- The best extended warranty companies for a particular purchase depend on product eligibility, exclusions, costs and claims handling.
- Retailer programmes and consumer subscriptions need separate assessments because they serve different purchasing needs.
- Claimlane supports warranty claims and returns workflows; it has a different role from the providers selling or administering protection plans.
What is an extended warranty?
An extended warranty usually refers to additional protection purchased for a product. In the US, the Federal Trade Commission distinguishes separately purchased service contracts from warranties included with a purchase.
The distinction matters because additional protection has its own terms. It may cover certain breakdowns, accidental damage or other events, depending on the contract.
Extra protection also does not automatically cover every problem after the original warranty ends. Buyers should check when coverage starts, what protection already exists and which exclusions apply.
How these five providers were selected
The providers below have published non-auto protection offerings relevant to retail products. Together, they represent retailer programmes, checkout protection and subscriptions covering eligible household purchases.
This is an editorial shortlist based on those offerings, rather than a ranking of customer satisfaction or claim approval rates. The numbered order does not indicate that one provider delivers better results than another.
A provider's brand name is only the starting point. The contract offered through a specific retailer can differ from another programme associated with the same company.
Top 5 extended warranty companies at a glance
| Provider | Published offering | Key comparison question |
|---|---|---|
| Allstate Protection Plans | Protection for phones, electronics, appliances, furniture and more | What does the plan offered for this purchase cover? |
| Asurion | Separate home technology and appliance protection offerings | Which programme includes the products needing protection? |
| Extend | Product protection offered through merchants | How will protection connect with checkout and support? |
| Assurant | Retailer protection programmes across several product categories | How will the programme support the retailer's range and service requirements? |
| Mulberry | Subscription protection for eligible online purchases | Which purchases qualify, and which limits apply? |
Availability and terms should be checked for the relevant product, retailer and location before a purchase or partnership decision.
1. Allstate Protection Plans
Allstate Protection Plans, associated with SquareTrade, lists protection for phones, electronics, appliances, furniture and other products. Its website also provides routes for registering plans and starting claims.
It belongs on a shortlist when the purchase falls within one of those categories and an applicable plan is available. The comparison should use the actual offer attached to the product.
Buyers should establish whether accidental damage is included, how a claim begins and what happens when a repair cannot be completed. Retailers should also clarify which enquiries remain with their own support team.
2. Asurion
Asurion publishes separate protection offerings for home technology and major appliances. Home+ lists devices such as televisions, computers, tablets and gaming systems, while Appliance+ addresses appliances such as refrigerators, washers and dryers.
Those programmes should be assessed separately. The published Home+ offering excludes mobile phones, and its coverage should not be assumed to include major appliances.
Asurion is a relevant comparison for households considering protection across eligible devices or appliances. Buyers should check current enrolment options, waiting periods, service fees and coverage limits for the specific programme.
3. Extend
Extend offers product protection through merchants, with published options addressing failures and accidental damage. Its merchant offering includes ecommerce integrations and APIs.
This makes it relevant to retailers evaluating how additional protection fits into the purchase journey. The decision involves both the customer-facing offer and the work required to support it.
A retailer's demonstration should follow an eligible product from checkout through a claim. The review should establish how order information reaches the protection programme, who communicates with the customer and what happens if the original purchase is returned.
4. Assurant
Assurant offers retailer protection programmes covering categories including electronics, appliances, home furnishings, jewellery and tools. Its published retail offering includes service and repair support alongside programme design.
It is a relevant candidate for retailers assessing protection across several product categories. The evaluation should focus on how the proposed programme would work for that retailer's products and operating model.
Questions should cover service availability, responsibility for customer communication and the treatment of products that cannot be repaired. A broad category list still needs to be translated into a specific programme and contract.
5. Mulberry
Mulberry Unlimited is a subscription offering for eligible online purchases. Its published benefits include repair, replacement or reimbursement, subject to the plan's terms.
Eligibility needs particular attention. The published exclusions include smartphones, laptops and tablets, among other product types. Product-value restrictions and an annual coverage limit also apply.
Mulberry is relevant when a buyer wants to assess protection across qualifying purchases from different online retailers. The buyer should check the products they expect to protect against the eligibility rules before comparing subscription costs.
Compare the events covered by each plan
Two plans can protect the same product category while covering different events. Mechanical breakdown, accidental damage and cosmetic damage should each have a clear treatment in the contract.
A furniture example shows why that matters. A broken mechanism, a liquid spill and gradual fabric wear describe different problems. Coverage for one does not establish coverage for the others.
A useful comparison records the covered event, exclusions, coverage period and available remedy together. That gives buyers a clearer view than a general promise of product protection.
For retailers, this detail should also appear in customer communications. Support teams need language that matches the plan being sold.
Compare total costs and settlement limits
The purchase price or monthly subscription is only one part of the cost. Depending on the plan, a claim may involve a deductible, service fee or other conditions affecting the value of the protection.
Buyers should also check the maximum benefit and how claims affect the remaining protection. A replacement or reimbursement may have consequences for the plan's continuation.
For a subscription, the comparison should use a realistic period of ownership and the products that actually qualify. A low recurring price is less useful when the intended purchase is excluded.
Retailers should assess programme economics alongside the support work they retain. Additional sales revenue alone does not explain the operational cost of handling confused customers or unresolved cases.
Check how a claim reaches a final outcome
Good extended warranty companies need to be assessed on the claim journey as well as the sales offer. Buyers should be able to understand where to report a problem and what information will be required.
A practical review follows a sample case through these stages:
- Confirming the purchase and applicable protection.
- Collecting evidence of the reported problem.
- Assessing the issue against the contract.
- Arranging an approved repair or other remedy.
- Explaining the outcome and closing any remaining work.
For bulky products, the review should include collection, transport and access arrangements. For devices, it should establish whether repair requires a visit, shipment or service-centre appointment.
These are evaluation questions, rather than claims that every provider follows the same process.
Define the retailer's responsibilities before launch
A customer may contact the retailer first, even when another company administers the protection. The retailer needs a clear way to identify the plan and explain the next step.
Before launch, the parties should agree who handles eligibility questions, evidence requests, status updates, complaints and exceptions. The agreement should also cover cancellations and changes to the original order.
A refunded product, exchanged item or corrected customer address can affect several records. Those changes need a defined owner and a reliable way to reach the relevant systems.
The programme should be tested with a difficult case as well as a straightforward one. A missing receipt or unavailable replacement can reveal gaps in the handoff between teams.
Match the provider to the products and market
The best extended warranty companies for one retailer may be unsuitable for another. Product range, customer location and service requirements should determine the shortlist.
A furniture seller needs answers about bulky-item handling and repair arrangements. An electronics merchant needs clear device eligibility. A retailer with several categories needs consistent support without assuming every product follows identical rules.
This comparison focuses on published US offerings. A business operating elsewhere should verify local availability, the contracting entity and the applicable terms before treating any provider as a candidate.
Multi-market retailers should evaluate each intended market explicitly. A provider's presence in one country does not establish that the same programme is available in another.
Where Claimlane fits into warranty operations
Extended protection introduces more cases, records and responsibilities into aftersales operations. Retailers still need to coordinate customer requests, internal decisions and any work assigned to suppliers or service partners.
Claimlane's warranty and returns workflows support the organisation of that work through routing, ownership and case actions. Its role should be assessed separately from the contract providing extended protection.
Any connection with a protection provider needs to be confirmed for the proposed setup. The retailer should establish which information is shared, which system records the decision and how outstanding work stays visible.
With Claimlane's help, we've been able to improve how our teams work together internally, not just how we communicate with the customer.
Riccardo Baldoni, Digital Director, Silver CrossClaimlane has a 4.8/5 rating on G2.
Frequently asked questions
Choose the protection and plan the service
A useful extended warranty comparison starts with the products that need protection and the events the contract covers. It then follows the claim through to a completed repair, replacement or other agreed outcome.
For retailers, that evaluation should include the work remaining with their own teams. Clear ownership and connected case records help staff explain what is happening when a customer asks for help.
Book a Claimlane demo to discuss how warranty claims and returns can be organised across customer service, suppliers and service teams.




