Claimlane vs ReturnLogic

ReturnLogic handles returns and exchanges. Claimlane handles what follows a faulty product: the repair, the spare part and the claim to the supplier.
G2 logo
4.8 ★★★★★
+45K businesses
Claimlane is used by leading brands and retailers worldwide
Angling Direct
BabySam
Hummel
ITW construction products
Tonies

What is the difference between Claimlane and ReturnLogic?

ReturnLogic is returns software for Shopify and BigCommerce brands, focused on refunds and exchanges, with warranty handled as one more return type. Claimlane covers the full aftersales process, from the customer’s first report to the supplier’s credit note: returns, warranty claims, repairs, spare parts and supplier claims. Each claim is routed by product and warranty rules, and can end in a repair, a spare part, a replacement or a claim to the supplier responsible. Retailers and dealers file claims in their own B2B portal, and the data syncs with Shopify, Magento, WooCommerce and Business Central.

ReturnLogic suits DTC brands whose returns are mostly exchanges; Claimlane suits brands and retailers whose returns are often faulty products.

Claimlane vs ReturnLogic

Claimlane
from $800€700/mo
ReturnLogic
Shopify app from $0/mo
What each platform covers
Returns management
Yes
Yes
Exchanges and replacement orders
Yes
Yes, including bonus credit
Warranty claims handling
Yes
Yes, as a return type, including third-party purchases
Customer-facing repair flows
Yes
No
Spare parts requests
Yes
No
Forward claims to suppliers
Yes
No
B2B claims portal for retailers and dealers
Yes
No
Warehouse and 3PL integration
Yes
Yes, ShipBob (beta)
ERP integration
Yes, Business Central
No ERP named, open API
Ecommerce platforms
Shopify, Magento, WooCommerce
Shopify, BigCommerce
Pricing
From $800€700/mo, published
Shopify app free or $49.50/mo; platform from $299/mo, usage-based ($3.90 to $0.25 per return), 12-month contract

Which one fits your business better: ReturnLogic or Claimlane?

Both handle returns and warranty requests. The difference is what happens after the request: a refund or an exchange, or a repair, a spare part and a claim to the supplier.

Your company
What your returns look like
Better fit
Why
Small Shopify brand starting with returns
A few dozen returns a month
ReturnLogic
Free plan or $49.50/mo in the Shopify App Store
DTC brand that wants to keep revenue
Many returns are size or style swaps
ReturnLogic
Exchanges with bonus credit and full-catalog exchanges
BigCommerce store
Standard returns and refunds
ReturnLogic
Native BigCommerce support
Brand with volume that changes by season
Return volume goes up and down
ReturnLogic
Usage-based pricing per return
Brand selling durable or technical products
Faults that may be fixed instead of refunded
Claimlane
Repair flows and spare parts requests
Retailer selling many brands
Defects must go back to the supplier
Claimlane
Claims forwarded with photos and tracked until credited
Brand selling through dealers or stores
Partners file claims for end customers
Claimlane
B2B portal for retailers and dealers
Company on Business Central
Order and credit data live in the ERP
Claimlane
Native integrations, credit notes in the ERP
Shopify brand already using ReturnLogic
Exchanges work well, warranty cases still go by email
Both side by side
ReturnLogic for returns and exchanges, Claimlane for warranty, repairs and supplier claims

Four ways Claimlane is different from ReturnLogic

ReturnLogic is built to turn a return into an exchange. Claimlane is built for the cases where the product is faulty and someone has to decide whether to fix it, replace a part or send the cost back to the supplier.
View pricing
Brands and retailers that run aftersales in Claimlane see the difference in their numbers:
  • Black Diamond, a climbing and outdoor equipment brand selling through its webshop and retailers: the SLA for warranty and repair cases is now 5 days, down from 25.
  • Onyx Cookware, a kitchenware brand with separate Shopify stores in 30+ countries: 30% fewer people needed on support tickets.
  • Konges Sløjd, a baby and nursery brand sold through 1,000+ retailers in 80+ countries: 66% less time spent on each retailer claim, with credits booked straight into Business Central.
More than 800,000 claims a year run through Claimlane, from the first report to the refund, repair or credit note.

Why brands choose Claimlane

Built for complex products

ReturnLogic handles returns and exchanges well for apparel and accessories, where the answer is usually a new size or a refund. Bikes, furniture, electronics and appliances are different: the customer reports a fault, and the brand needs photos, serial numbers and a decision. Claimlane asks for that information at the start and routes each case by product, fault and market.

Warranty claims, not just returns

In ReturnLogic, warranty is a return type that ends in a replacement or a refund. In Claimlane, a warranty claim can also end in a repair at a service partner, a spare part sent to the customer or a claim to the supplier. Warranty rules are set per product and market, so agents don’t check terms by hand.

Connects with suppliers

ReturnLogic has no workflow for passing a defect to the supplier. Claimlane forwards the claim with the customer’s photos and documentation attached, tracks the supplier’s answer and records the credit note, so retailers recover the cost of faulty products instead of absorbing it.

B2B and B2C

ReturnLogic is built for the shopper returning an online order. Claimlane also gives retailers, dealers and wholesale customers their own portal, where they file claims on behalf of end customers and follow each case until it is resolved. Claims from shoppers and from business partners land in the same system, with separate rules and terms for each.

Still weighing your options? See how Claimlane compares with other tools in our guide to ReturnLogic alternatives.

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose ReturnLogic or Claimlane?

Choose ReturnLogic if:
  • you are a Shopify or BigCommerce brand and most returns are size or style exchanges
  • you want to start on a free or low-cost Shopify app
  • you prefer to pay per return
Choose Claimlane if:
  • many of your returns are faulty products covered by warranty
  • you resolve claims with repairs or spare parts, not only refunds
  • defects should be passed back to the supplier
  • retailers or dealers need their own portal for claims
  • you sell on Magento or WooCommerce or run Business Central

Does ReturnLogic handle warranty claims?

Yes, as a return type. Shoppers can submit warranty returns, including for products bought on marketplaces such as Amazon or Walmart, and the outcome is a replacement or a refund. ReturnLogic has no repair flows, spare parts requests or supplier forwarding. Claimlane handles all three in the same claim.

How much does Claimlane cost compared to ReturnLogic?

Claimlane starts at $800€700/mo, with pricing published on its website. ReturnLogic’s Shopify app has a free plan and a Pro plan at $49.50/mo for 25 returns, plus $1.75 per extra return. Its full platform starts at $299/mo, with usage-based fees of $3.90 to $0.25 per return and a 12-month contract (as of October 2026).

Which ecommerce platforms do ReturnLogic and Claimlane support?

ReturnLogic supports Shopify and BigCommerce. Claimlane connects to Shopify, Magento, WooCommerce and Business Central. Order data syncs automatically, and refunds, replacement orders and credit notes flow back into the store or ERP.

Can I use ReturnLogic and Claimlane together?

Yes. A brand using Shopify can keep ReturnLogic for returns and exchanges and use Claimlane for warranty claims, repairs and supplier claims. Setup time for Claimlane depends on the number of markets, integrations and workflows.

“We don’t want things to be cumbersome or difficult, or for the customer to get frustrated halfway through a warranty claim. It has to be as seamless and easy as possible.”
Riccardo Baldoni, Digital Director
Riccardo Baldoni, Digital Director at Silver Cross

Claimlane integrates with every system you have

With our integrations, all your warranty claim and returns data is centralized. Get deep analytics and powerful automations that removes manual work from your processes.

We also offer API connections and provide support to build custom integrations if needed.

See what our customers have to say

Claimlane developers were really quick to answer my questions and could be easily booked on a call to discuss issues or change requests.

Elliot Landry
IT Supervisor

Claimlane implementation was a breeze to do, the documentation is clear and concise. 

Elliot Landry
IT Supervisor

Claimlane helps us resolve customer issues faster and with less friction, which makes a real difference for both our team and our customers.

Anne Schmidt
Project Manager, Ergobaby

With Claimlane’s help, we’ve been able to improve how our teams work together internally, not just how we communicate with the customer.

Riccardo Baldoni
Digital Director, Silver Cross

From where we started with Claimlane to where we are now, the platform has advanced so much in such a short space of time.

Riccardo Baldoni
Digital Director, Silver Cross

Claimlane has become an extension of Silver Cross. They understand our business, work flexibly with us and help us build the solution we actually need.

Riccardo Baldoni
Digital Director, Silver Cross

For a business with so many different products and markets like ours, it has been crucial to have a solution that is both robust and flexible. Claimlane and their support have made a big difference in our daily work.

Simone Nybo
Customer Relationship Manager, Søstrene Grene

Learning how to use Claimlane was almost the easiest part because everything is where it needs to be and it's very comprehensible. I would say it only took about 5 minutes to get a good overview of the platform.

Izabella Råberg
Customer Service Manager, Ganni

I can handle 5-10 claims in Claimlane during the time it takes to handle 1 via email.

David Outen
Returns Coordinator, The Hut Group

With 500 suppliers who all have their own guidelines it has been impossible to keep track. Claimlane has simplified the processes for both customers and suppliers and removed a major stress factor in the whole organization.

Andreas Bang Nielsen
Marketing & Ecommerce Director, Davidsen

Claimlane has created the best RMA process we've ever had. We no longer have any outstandings with suppliers and have an overview at all times.

Jesper Andersen
CCO, GEJSER

With Claimlane, we have a unified Returns and Claims system for all revenue streams, ensuring streamlined access and data storage. This unified setup across channels is critical to optimize operational workflows.

Christopher Jarrov
Head of Supply Chain, Rains

Claimlane is brilliant because it collects everything about claim warranties in one place. All data is correctly received the first time, and there is no confusion. Overall it gives the opportunity to deliver better customer service, save tons of time and get a more structured knowledge about repeating defects.

Claire Boeltoft
Head of Customer Relations, WODEN

Claims that once meant days of back-and-forth get resolved in a fraction of the time.

Cameron Darnell
Warranty Manager, Angling Direct

For the first time, we can see every warranty claim across all our stores and webshops in one place.

Cameron Darnell
Warranty Manager, Angling Direct

It was amazing how easy it was to roll out the Claimlane platform. The support during the rollout has been fantastic, and it played an essential role in onboarding our stores and wholesalers.

Nicklas Smedegård
Business Controller, Skechers

Before Claimlane, every case required manually digging around to find the best solution. Now we move faster and with real confidence. You can feel the impact within our support team and in every customer interaction.

Jacob Bay
Chief Operating Officer, MaxGaming

Claimlane enables us to centralize all our post-purchase operations. Instead of juggling multiple tools, everything from ticket intake to supplier collaboration is handled in one place.

Simone Andersen
Customer Service Director, Coolshop

Electronic cases can be complex, and sometimes a new issue would come in that the support agent hadn’t handled before. That combination often slowed down our response time.

Nick Magnusson
Head of Customer Service, MaxGaming

A dissatisfied mom will also take 10 of her closest friends with her if she leaves your business because of a negative experience.

Kenneth Nørgaard
CEO, BabySam

Managing warranty claims and repairs across such a wide range of products used to be messy. Claimlane gives us a setup that keeps everything organized and easy to handle. It helps us respond faster and deliver the level of service our customers expect from us.

Tess Jordan
Senior Manager of Customer Experience

By streamlining and automating our support workflows in Claimlane, we not only accelerated our customer service response times but also enhanced the overall system experience, internally and externally.

Mikael Houlst Stausholm
Sales Director, Konges Sløjd

A claim on a sofa isn’t like a T-shirt. It’s a bulky product with lots of parts, and figuring out what’s wrong used to take a lot of time. Claimlane helps us identify the issue instantly.

Camillia Ahm
Customer Experience Coordinator and Head of Claims, MøbelKompagniet

With the integration to Business Central, resolving a claim in Claimlane automatically triggers all the necessary processes in our ERP. This means the customer service agent’s work is complete the moment the claim is resolved in Claimlane.

Kasper Andersen
IT Director, Konges Sløjd

The customer's issue gets solved much faster, and that is absolutely key. We want a good and effective partnership with our retailers.

Samira Nobakhti-Afshar
Sales Support Specialist, Konges Sløjd

"Claimlane gives us a full view of a customer’s claim history and integrates with our Shopify data. That helps us judge: is this a loyal customer or a one-time buyer?"

Tanja Munch
Head of Customer Service

"Before, we sent an email to the supplier, and then we waited and had to follow up. With Claimlane, the supplier sees everything clearly, and we can track what's going on."

Tanja Munch
Head of Customer Service

"Issuing refunds and replacements without switching between systems has been a huge time saver for our team."

Patrick Zangenberg
Head of Customer Service

"Before Claimlane, our customer could expect their claim to involve back-and-forth emails and be quite time-consuming, now a claim will be submitted at 8:00 AM and resolved at 10:00 AM"

Rasmus Andersen
Chief Operating Officer, Onyx Cookware

"Before Claimlane, our customer could expect their claim to involve back-and-forth emails and be quite time-consuming, now a claim will be submitted at 8:00 AM and resolved by 10:00 AM”

Rasmus Andersen
Chief Operating Officer, Onyx Cookware

“With Claimlane, we've transformed our returns process into a streamlined, automated system. We can now efficiently track the status of all returns and claims, and our teams collaborate more effectively than ever before. In short, the solution helps us streamline communication and share information both internally and externally, which has been key to our success."

Simone Andersen
Customer Care Manager, Coolshop

“Whether customers are shopping in-store or online, their expectations are, quite rightly, increasing every day. We, therefore, decided the time was right to invest in our vital online aftercare service, something which many retailers often overlook, despite its power to make or break a retailer’s reputation if they do not get it spot-on.”

Elisa Schjødt Frank
Head of Customer Success, Matas A/S

Before Claimlane, our entire customer service team of 5 agents was involved in claims handling, with additional seasonal help from other departments. Today, we have 1-2 agents who can solve everything in Claimlane.

Andreas Bang Nielsen
Marketing & Ecommerce Director, Davidsen

With Claimlane, we can process the cases significantly faster than before, and at the same time, we get the right data per claim and thus valuable insight for improvement.

Benny Kristiansen
Former Chief Sales Officer, Sebra

Claimlane helps us capture every customer issue, resolve it for the customer, and feed that back to the supply chain to drive continuous improvement.

Henry Currer
Head of Operations, Swoon Furniture

Claimlane has revolutionized our operational efficiency, paving the way for streamlined processes and improved customer experiences.

Riccardo Baldoni
Associate Director of IT & CX, Silver Cross

We save both time and money by not having to call back faulty products from our retailers, which is also better for the environment. Now, we can judge a claim just from a picture.

Victoria Klitvad
Sales Support, Mads Nørgaard

We achieved our ROI almost immediately by implementing Claimlane.

Jesper Nielsen
Head of Customer Service, GrejFreak

If you removed your product tomorrow I would start to cry

Mia Fjelsted
Customer Service Specialist, LuksusBaby

Claimlane's Self-Service Portal has revolutionized how our customers submit their requests and eliminated the need for phone calls and email exchanges.

Adnan Baessa
Head of Operations, Cult

With Claimlane there is no need to write many emails back and forth, as customers cannot submit claims without all the needed information.

Betina Kyed
Returns & Claims Manager, F.Engel K/S

Due to the perfectly documented complaints with photos, issue codes, etc. communication with customers is effortless. We have reduced our resolution time from 4 days to 1 day.

Sandra Smith
Customer Service Manager, Liewood

See Claimlane in action

See how Claimlane handles warranty claims between your brand, retail partners and suppliers.